Why do Insurance Producers Fail?

3 min read

Because my firm specializes in insurance brokerage recruiting in the WDC region, I get a lot of calls from WDC area insurance brokerage hiring authorities asking me, “why do insurance producers fail?” The answers may surprise you…

I have fielded this question so many times this year that I now feel obliged to pass along my findings to my hiring authority colleagues. It is interesting just how similar the executive search business is to the insurance brokerage business.

It turns out that many of the same reasons why insurance sales producers are not producing new business are nearly the same reasons why my own recruiters are sometimes not successful. I will address the primary two reasons below:

It’s a Numbers Game: it’s amazing just how many sales managers have not figured out the metrics of their own sales organization. For sure, each organization is going to be a little different, but across my client base, it’s pretty much the same process:

  • Segment your market and identify/develop your niche,
  • Get a list of those companies and identify the decision-maker
  • Make the calls
  • Establish the telcon connection and make an introductory presentation
  • Schedule the sales presentation meeting
  • Close the deal

When the dust settles, fine tune your activity metrics and benchmarks

A typical insurance sales metric: 1) 100 targeted calls = 50 telcon presentations = 15 sales meetings/pitches = 3 deals using a 5:1 closing ratio. Repeat the same process 3 – 5 times over the next 90 days.

So why doesn’t every sales producer do this? Because many times there are no communicated benchmarks and/or metrics to measure activity against. There is no real accountability. If benchmarks and metrics are not measured on a regular basis and enforced, they do not exist. It’s just human nature.

Every sales organization has to determine their own metrics and benchmarks. Once this is done and effectively communicated to the producers AND measured each week or month in a group setting, your sales producers will either perform or realize they need help. Post it in the conference room so everyone can see how their phone/meeting activity fared against their peers. Believe me, nobody wants to be last. For new hires, within 60 days you will know the posers from the producers. Keeping unproductive producers around too long is one of the costliest mistakes you will ever make.

It’s amazing how similar our sales models really are because I sit down with my recruiters at the beginning of each quarter and remind them of how many outgoing calls they will have to make to prospective candidates to make $xxxx for the year. After ten years of doing this myself, I know the numbers. And at the end of the year, we tally up the calls from our call accounting system and, sure enough, the sales commissions they generate from placements are within a margin of error of +/- 5%. Amazing. As such, they look forward to making the calls every day! Because they know the metrics.


Do you know your metrics?

If you don’t have the metrics for a particular P& C or EB sector, just call me and I will give them to you.

I have the averages.

Ability to Connect: Throughout the years, my best entry-level placements have been with young teachers and journalists/reporters. Why is this so? Because they can CONNECT with people. They have advanced active listening skills. Listening and clarifying are in their DNA.

I was just telling someone this morning over breakfast about a well-known insurance brokerage client that invited me down to their headquarters office for some consultations on compensation structure and, afterward, I was invited to a company function where some of their insurance top insurance producers were present. I was asked to interact with some of them and guess who the #1 nationwide producer was.

I was astonished to find out that the #1 producer was a non-descript individual sitting off in the corner of the crowded bar area reading the WSJ. I introduced myself and ended up having a 30-minute conversation about a wide range of topics from family to sports to music to travel. This slightly pudgy and horn-rimmed individual could really connect. And he listened to what I had to say. By the time I left the table, I really felt like I had made a new friend. He could CONNECT.

Tough to measure on a personality profile or in a resume. But when you feel it, you know it. Look for it in your next candidate. Funny thing was that I asked him about his activity metrics and he knew his closing ratio to the decimal point.

Are your producers talking or are they connecting?

Your thoughts and feedback are important to us and greatly appreciated!


Recent Posts